NYC News Network | Local News Across New York City
Italianissimo 30 years is more than just an anniversary—it’s a rare survival story in New York City’s brutal restaurant industry, and Staten Island diners are taking notice.
In South Beach, where neighborhood spots come and go, Italianissimo has quietly built a reputation for consistency, tradition, and deeply loyal customers who keep coming back—sometimes even from out of state.
The milestone moment for Italianissimo 30 years arrives this spring, as Chef Franco Ortega celebrates three decades tied to the beloved Staten Island restaurant at 107 McClean Avenue.
While the official anniversary nods to Ortega’s long tenure, the restaurant itself dates back to 1996, when it was opened by the Fanizza brothers in a space that once housed another Italian eatery.
Ortega, who took over the business in 2006 and later became sole owner, is planning a community celebration in June to mark the occasion, bringing together longtime customers and neighbors who helped shape the restaurant’s identity.
For many in South Beach, the milestone feels personal.
The story behind Italianissimo 30 years starts far from the spotlight—at a sink.
Ortega began his career as a dishwasher, working his way up through the kitchen before eventually taking ownership. That hands-on experience still defines how he runs the restaurant today.
Rather than chasing food trends, Ortega has stayed committed to traditional Italian cooking, particularly dishes inspired by southern Italy’s Puglia region.
Signature items like panzerotti—a mini calzone served in the bread basket—have been part of the menu since day one. Other staples include orecchiette, Sunday sauce, grilled seafood, and the restaurant’s widely praised house-made focaccia.
The kitchen’s philosophy is simple: fresh ingredients, no shortcuts.
Ortega still personally shops for fish and meat several times a week, selecting items he would serve to his own family.
Reaching Italianissimo 30 years is no small feat in a city where restaurant turnover is constant—and often unforgiving.
In Staten Island, the restaurant has become more than just a place to eat. It’s a gathering spot for families, celebrations, and returning residents who make it a must-visit when they’re back in town.
Some customers now living in Florida or elsewhere still plan their trips around a stop at Italianissimo.
That kind of loyalty speaks to something deeper than food.
The restaurant has built a reputation for flexibility and personal touch. Instead of rigid menus, Ortega often tailors dishes based on what customers are craving that week, whether it’s baked clams, stuffed squash blossoms, or seafood specialties.
For group dining, that approach turns a meal into something more communal—and more memorable.
Even notable figures have taken notice over the years. Ortega recalls serving a former New York City mayor and actor Robert De Niro, who kept things classic with white clam sauce and garlic bread.
The success of Italianissimo 30 years comes at a time when many longtime New York restaurants are struggling to stay afloat.
Rising costs, staffing challenges, and shifting dining habits have made longevity increasingly rare—especially for independently owned neighborhood spots.
Across the five boroughs, closures have become more common, while newer restaurants often lean into trends or fast-casual models to survive.
Italianissimo stands apart by doing the opposite.
Instead of reinventing itself, the restaurant has leaned into tradition—proof that there’s still a strong appetite for classic, no-frills Italian cooking done well.
At the same time, Ortega has made subtle updates to keep pace with changing tastes, including adding gluten-free pasta and pizza options and expanding outdoor dining during the pandemic.
It’s a balance many restaurants struggle to achieve.
Looking ahead, Italianissimo 30 years is less about slowing down and more about continuing a legacy.
The restaurant is preparing to reopen its outdoor deck in the coming weeks, with an expanded menu aimed at both longtime regulars and new visitors.
The upcoming June celebration is expected to draw a mix of loyal customers and community members, marking not just a business milestone but a neighborhood moment.
For Ortega, the future also carries a personal dimension.
These days, he’s often seen with his young grandson at the restaurant—a possible sign that the next generation is already being introduced to the family business.
In a city where restaurants often burn bright and fade fast, Italianissimo’s story is something different.
It’s about staying power, consistency, and the kind of connection that turns a local spot into a landmark.
What is Italianissimo known for?
Italianissimo is known for its old-school Italian dishes, including panzerotti, orecchiette, seafood plates, and house-made focaccia.
Where is Italianissimo located?
The restaurant is located in South Beach, Staten Island, at 107 McClean Avenue.
Is Italianissimo doing anything for its 30th anniversary?
Yes, the restaurant is planning a community celebration in June and will reopen its outdoor dining space with an expanded menu.